Simple challenges come in the form of a difficulty level, roughly 1-20. If half your total (Capability + Profession) is enough, you're all set. If your total is enough, spend one Reserve to make it. If you need a higher value, spend more Reserve to boost your score at a 1:1 rate.
You may want to use double instead of half, and double the difficulty chart, depending on which is easier for people to figure out lighting fast. (For me, at least, I can instantly remember that double thirteen is 26, but I have to think for a moment to determine that half thirteen is 6.5 (“Thirteen is one more than twelve, so half-thirteen is ½ more than six”)).
Unimportant contests are solved by comparing totals. Higher one wins. This is used when the result doesn't particularly matter to the players and GM, and they just want to get a resolution and move on.
I like! Lighting fast, and lets capable characters simply trump not-terribly-interesting situations. If either the player or the GM want it to be interesting, they can switch to a full-on conflict. This pretty-much codifies what I do anyway. (“You’re a stored with Cog 10 and Programmer 10. No, you do not need to roll to hack the cargo-cultist's home computer.”)
Conflicts go like this:
I have a problem with some of this. Let’s say I'm a cargo-cultist ninja fighting a mechanican. My goal is to incapacitate the mechanican (preventing it from shooting me or my allies) and my first move is to slip up the wall and drop down on it from above. The mechanican's goal is to shoot at me until I go away, and it’s first move is to detonate the air in front of it with an inversion beam, heating up the room. We each spend a reserve so we can fight (ante). So far so good.
Now, my total is 8, and the mechanican's is 14. So… I burn 7 reserve to beat the mechanican. The mechanican burns 2 to reserve to beat me. I burn 2 more to beat it. It burns 2 more to beat me. I give up, being nearly out of reserve.
The problem with that last paragraph was that there was no role-playing involved. Oh, certainly I could describe jumping over the mechanican and tossing throwing stars at it, and it could describe spraying laser fire in my wake. But none of those descriptions would change the results of the combat at all. Indeed, I could just say "I walk up to the mechanican's face and punch it" each time I spent reserve, and it would have the same effects in-game, despite being entirely unrealistic and boring.
The other problem is that you run the risk of dollar auctions, where it's worth burning just one (or two) more reserve to win… when you’ve already spent (and will lose) a lot of reserve even if you lose. Conflicts would tend to be massive, with both sides using up all of their reserve for even relatively unimportant contests.
So, I propose several alternatives:
The quick RP-less option:
Instead of bidding up reserve, both sides simultaneously bid reserve once (without knowing the other's bid). Higher total (capability+profession+reserve) wins. The advantage here is speed and the ability to bluff, and lack of dollar auctions.
The RP = points option:
Both sides describe their actions when they spend reserve. The GM rewards additional points for cool descriptions.
The mixed option:
Both sides decide their actions and reserve bid simultaneously. Then, each side describes what they intend to do (without taking into account what the opponent was intending; this can be tricky). The GM (or a vote of players) reward free reserve to the best description (and the one that would "win" when the two characters do opposing things; this strongly weakens one-trick ponies as the enemy can quickly adapt to their descriptions and counter the one thing they do). Then the two sides reveal their reserve expenditure, add the bonus points, and compare.
Optionally, this can be repeated over several rounds, until either one side runs out of reserve or one side wins by a large enough margin.
To the victor, the spoils:
I very much like the idea of interesting complications as results for conflicts.
I'm not sure that complications should be based on reserve expenditure. The fact that you had to work harder to win doesn't mean that you should win less. Maybe it should be based on the amount by which you won? So a margin of 3 is really nasty, while a margin of 1 is pyrric. I know that your system is based on hp loss in Mouseguard, but Mouseguard has a RPS system to randomize results, and anyway this system is different enough from Mouseguard that I'm not convinced that it would work the way you want.
I've been experimenting with the "player picks their own complications for every roll" idea in the RPG I’ve been designing. I haven't had the chance to test it out, but I think it has promise. The only think I'd recommend is to let the player choose not to pick their own complication (hand it to the GM). At least one of my players would never want to pick his own complication (and, as such, never ever spends more than one twist in a session when we play SA).
Random notes:
I stole the "simultaneous bid" idea from my fuzzy memories of Nobilis. I think Mouse Guard's complication system is part of Burning Wheel (being based largely on that, and written by the same guy). That said, I haven't read Burning Wheel yet.
Alternatively, if you want to give the enemy a catastrophic complication (death) and can't manage better than a major one, give them a catastrophic complication and yourself a minor one.
CVs providing reserve is an excellent idea. It also fits. If you deeply care about something, you're able to find inner reserves of strength to continue fighting for it.
When you do environment/tool bonuses, I strongly recommend including stunt bonuses.
In general, I really like this system. I just think that it needs a little work.