In Sorcerously Advanced, your soul is your shadow.
If you want to inscribe magical wards and protections on your soul, you can do it. You just need a steady light source or some way to pin your shadow in place, and and a steady hand with some fancy inks or reagents. This is a fairly standard thing at Soul 2+. Most people from Traditions involving runes, geometry, written spells, etc. will have things inscribed on their soul.
If someone has no shadow, they have no soul. Or there's an illusion involved. Also, just because it's noon doesn't mean your soul goes away. Even if you're in a room that is magically lit from all sides so there's no shadow, there's still shadow inside you. You can close your eyes and summon your power and it will call up the protections written on your soul so that you can see them, inspect them, activate them.
The soul is imperishable, but not indestructible. That is, you can split it up, sell it, steal it, trade it, damage it, tear it, something can gnaw on it, you can have it stretched thin like butter over too much bread, but it will never be completely destroyed. If it's damaged, but you haven't given any of it away or had any of it sorcerously stolen and preserved, it will eventually regrow. If someone steals it, it's still your soul and not theirs. If it's destroyed in their possession, it regrows on you, not them. If you sell or trade a piece, that's theirs now, and it regrows in their possession.
There are definitely afterlives in this game, and your soul goes there with an option for reincarnation. If you sold part of your soul, it's still part-sold when you reincarnate. If someone stole it, it's still stolen when you come back.
What does it actually do, though?
What are you like without it?
Why would someone want it?
This I'm not sure about yet.
I briefly considered having a soulless state as being equivalent to disconnecting from the Self-Nature, but then I remembered that I had based the repercussions of being disconnected from Self on real-world psychological conditions. Implying that everyone with a dissociative disorder is soulless is a terrible idea. We ain't gonna do that.
Traditionally, being soulless means being listless, insipid, without inspiration, gaining no joy from life. Basing the effects of soullessness on depression (or many people's idea of depression, anyway) doesn't sound great either.
I could have the soul be each person's connection to magic, the connection point to the Gift. There's plenty of support in "the literature" for that (and by "the literature" I mean "Mage: The Ascension"), but I feel like there's a more interesting story and setup if that's not the case. Having serious opponents who are soulless but still powerful is a common enough trope that I don't want to throw it away. Also, if you can keep someone from doing magic by stealing their soul, that would be everyone's first plan of attack against every enemy, and that's boring.
Some fantasy settings connect the soul with the conscience. As an atheist, I can't help but see parallels between this and the idea that only through religion do people gain morality. I could rant against that bullshit for months. History has given me enough material for months. However, in SsA, the soul is a literal fact of life that is physically present and basically undeniable, so that helps to cut out some of those connotations. Losing your Core Values when you lose your soul is a possibility. Having them shunted to the extremes is also a possibility: any CV at 3+ becomes a 5, anything 2- becomes a 0. You're instantly a zealot.
I feel like there should be a noticeable pain to having no soul. Maybe someone without a soul even picks up a Core Value, "Make the Pain Stop", that starts at 0 and rises to 5. Depends how creepy I want to get.
Vulnerability to possession? Definitely want that. Even if they can only influence rather than taking over, it's a big vulnerability.
It should be possible to regrow your soul, even if it's been completely stolen. I feel like it should be difficult. More quest material than just waiting and resting.
What would someone do with the pieces of it? Why would you trade for someone's soul? It would definitely count as a mystical connection, so they could work magic on you directly through it. Does it increase their own magical power? Can they command you? (No, that A: circumvents the Gift, and B: again makes soul-theft everyone's first plan of attack.) Ok well failing that can they influence your CVs? Can they bend the things you do to benefit them? (This one I like, I'm just not sure how to implement it yet.) Do they build real powerful magical shit out of it? If so… uh… how are you going to get it back now?
Suggestions welcome.





