So far I had paid little attention to SoA, since I was under the mistaken impression it was going to impose narrow thematic limits on the kind of magic the default character was able to do. I am a big fan of generalist characters with a very broad set of magical abilities, so this was a serious turn off to me. Mandatory narrow specializations are a big RPG no-no to me. Then I got to read the Alpha, and I was very pleasantly surprised. This promises to be as excellent a game in its own way as SoA and I'll definitely follow and support its development. Even so, I think my SoA characters are most likely going to have multiple Traditions. At first glance, I suppose I especially like combining any two (or three!) pairs of Exercise, Language, or Wild Magic (perhaps Blood Magic too, although I fancy it a bit less) with Arete, Earthpower, or Elementalism (perhaps Necromancy too, although I usually find the ghosts and zombies stuff rather unappealing). What canon civilizations and traditions would be most suitable for this kind of character concepts, or perhaps I'd be better suited using brand-new ones (my main problem with using house civilizations/societies/traditions in SoA or SuA is I'm creatively challenged, esp. as it concerns fancy names)? How much the system and setting are going to be amenable with playing characters with multiple Traditions of the above kind?
On a similar note, I think I'm also going to prefer playing characters that have more or less maximized Natures, even above and beyond what multiple Traditions can provide, and can tap Polymath. I'm aware of the hard limits this is going to mean for Import, and I do not mind it. Much like my preferred approach to SuA character creation, I'd prefer to play the godlike powerhouse with terrible luck, rather than the lucky underdog. How conductive are the system and setting going to be for playing this kind of character, and are there to be differences from SuA?
It seems the game classifies Language as a Path that needs physical tools. I balk at this. As much as I can tell, this kind of magical technique generally has very little need for physical tools, more or less the same way as the techniques Exercise, Belief, Blood Magic, or Wild Magic represent. The vast majority of the time, these mages cast spells speaking or chanting incantations, tracing runes in the air, or writing them on the ground or on their own bodies (although the writing stuff might impinge on Geometry's turf). Even in the latter case, the writing medium often does not really matter, and in any case, blood can usually be an adequate and easily available solution. Only rarely they get to do something as elaborate as writing papers or scrolls or drawing complex symbols, when specific writing tools and materials do matter (and in this case, Geometry might be a better fit to represent the technique). As such, it seems to me Language does not have a real need for physical tools, and should be classified as such, with the relevant Advantage. It may be easily paired with the Disadvantage that the character needs to be able to speak and/or gesture to perform magic.
If I have multiple Founts, do their unique abilities benefits stack, or are they locked within their respective Traditions? E.g. is it possible to combine the Null Zone boons from Arete and Necromancy, or the Ideal Form boons from Earthpower and Elementalism? Likewise, do the barred techniques limitations only apply within their own Tradition, or all the time for a multi-Tradition character? Does it make a difference if multiple Founts share the same Path, or are tied to different Paths?
What about having three (or more!) Traditions? E.g. I can see a potential appeal from having more method flexibility and tapping multiple unique abilities, not to mention some broader thematic association, with combining three Founts, such as Arete, Earthpower, and Elementalism. Having three Paths, on the other hand does seem a bit redundant.
If I have multiple Traditions, and I maximize Natures for all of them, does the Import tax for breaking tradition limits apply only once, or for every Tradition?
In the likely case a character with multiple Founts gets Immortality from all of them, what happens to the special vulnerabilities? Do all of them need to be fulfilled to kill the character, or just one of them?
I fail to understand why Basin magic is bad at detecting disease, it seems hard to justify unlike the other limits.
There seems to be an overrepresentation of Belief and a underrepresentation of Exercise. This is unfortunate, since Belief tends to narrow options for character creation and tie down a limited valuable resource (CV) - even more so if the character belongs in a Society and/or has multiple Traditions that rely on different kinds of Belief - and does not fit much else than being a fanatic for an ideal or cause. Exercise is a broad and flavorful technique that is very good to represent personal excellence, mentalism, and/or physical training.
Someplace in the discussion of Mana, it states Wild Magic is better than other Traditions to manage chaotic Mana. Is this a significant effect in terms of Tradition special features, or just fluff?