(Note: This thread is for both SA2 and SsA.)
I keep coming across places where a standard disadvantage would be useful to have, in the same way that Competitive Advantage is the standard high-level advantage.
For reference, here's what Competitive Advantage does:
- +1 in conflicts before multiplication (so it's like +1 to CV or Profession).
- Change one of the Four Questions from "no to "maybe" or from "maybe" to "yes".
- Enable lateral strategies, where you take a -1 Capability (or Nature) and do things you normally couldn't because of your stats. This is perhaps the most powerful bit.
This is not as easy as it might look. I can't just throw a negative sign into the equation and have it work. Pure point balance is a game design idea from an older generation of games, and there's a reason you don't see it as much in modern systems. Providing a penalty to a single Nature, Capability, or especially Profession is not equivalent to providing a bonus for those, because characters are built toward advantages and away from disadvantages.
For instance, if you have an artist who sucks at police work, or a trickster who is bad at healing… that doesn't often matter. Those are typical character traits, not genuine disadvantages. Only unusual character concepts are going to run into a problem with those, and character traits are only disadvantages when they come into play in a way that negatively impacts your character. That's why Mutants & Masterminds doesn't have flaws that grant character points, it has Complications. It's why Vices in Chronicles of Darkness give you willpower as you play rather than bonus points at chargen. It's why Nobilis Bonds and Afflictions both give you Miracle Points when they interfere with you. It's also where the Big Deal rule comes from. You have to balance benefits that matter with problems that are equally significant, not with problems you can easily avoid.
As a rough estimate, if you were to create a Competitive Disadvantage that's just the negative of Competitive Advantage, I'd say getting CA in one Nature/Capability would be worth CD in just over half of your remaining scores. I'd do a 3:1 deal in SsA or a 2:1 deal in SA2.
In other games things would be different, but not by a ton. Most people who play D&D fighters would happily take +2 Strength at the cost of -2 in Wisdom, Intelligence, and Charisma, because they use Strength for over 50% of what they do and their mental stats for maybe 5% each. The penalty would narrow the field of strongly viable character concepts, but in the end it would impact players' chargen decisions much more than their in-play decisions.
Right now I'm just mulling this over in my head. If anyone has suggestions I'm open to them. My final decision will definitely be something that doesn't invoke Twists directly, but it might act on Complications or Advantages (as per the SsA civilization advantages), and it will probably have multiple aspects to it. I'm hoping to eventually come up with multiple tiers of things rather than just one thing that balances Competitive Advantage.





