This discussion thread spins out of the Beta rules discussion (where we hit the reply depth limit). I thought it would be a good idea to have it as a separate thread as well. I wanted to give folks a view of what I'm trying to accomplish so that we can be on the same page as to what will be in the core rules.
SA has had a LOT of game mechanics revisions. For every published version (including betas) there have been about a dozen rules systems and tweaks thereof that were discarded. All of them had the same underlying "world" that I was trying to emulate, but each did things differently and/or better.
Special note: Of all the threads on this site, I think this is the one that will need to be updated the most. I can't always remember some of the core assumptions that shaped the game, because some of them are just so ingrained that I forget them. Sometimes I even change them to make a better game. Check this list before posting. I'll try to keep a "last changed" date up here. Last changed: March 21 2013 - added Motifs
Major design goals:
- Play the character you want to play right away. This resulted in a game with no XP, and no limit on starting character Professions or Capabilities.
- Characters at all levels of skill and power are viable. This led to Themes.
- Emulate stories like those in the Inspirations list. This is a check-off item for me to make sure the system works properly.
- Instantly murdering the PCs is perfectly logical in the setting, but a dick move in a game. This obviously led to the Obligatory Instant Death Cutscene Rule.
Minor design goals:
- It would be nice if the game were playable while hiking or driving.
- It would be nice if the game were diceless.
- It would be nice if min-maxing were so easy that everyone could do it, and most people didn't even notice they were doing it.
- It would be nice if there were a way to have a story wherein someone grows in power or expertise without needing to nerf your starting character. Unfortunately, this goal was crushed by the first major design goal.
Major game mechanics assumptions:
- A character's skill is of equal importance with the amount of built-in technology that character has. Individuals may have more or less in each category, but the battle of the phenomenally skilled against the phenomenally enhanced is a draw.
- When you believe in something, you are more effective at accomplishing it.
- It's hard to talk people out of, and easy to talk them into, doing things they believe in.
- Game fiction sets the parameters for conflict. In the simplest sort of example, you can't punch someone at a range of a hundred meters, but you can sure shoot them from there. This seems obvious enough to me that I've never written it into the rules.
Minor game mechanics assumptions:
- Not all conflicts are equivalent. A bench-press competition is not the same as a martial arts form competition is not the same as a martial arts brawl. I think this may need to be increased to "major" at this point - it's clear that I haven't made this case strongly enough in 2nd edition.
- Teamwork matters. There is no conservation of ninjutsu.
- Doing things without people noticing is hard.
- Various other little things that are codified into rules at this point.
Major story-terms assumptions:
- When your opportunities are unlimited, your beliefs shape what you become.
- The things that you care about are the only things you won't change about yourself.
- When everyone in a society is smarter and more socially capable, people work together better, there is less crime, and folks are nicer to each other.
- The future is fairly bright and optimistic. Connected to the last one, but separable, and pre-dates it.
Epistemological standpoints:
- Death is the cessation of physical continuity. This was a standpoint in 1st edition (thus the "replicators are death" rule). Since I've come to think that physical continuity is an illusion, we have the new Existentialism rules, which other people seem to like better anyway.
- Your beliefs are what make you you - not your body, not your brain, not your training, but what you believe. Everything else is ok to change and still be yourself. This is why "CVs changed" is a critical complication. I'm not strict on this standpoint, which is why the Rule of Intent exists.
Motifs
- The effects of technology on society and on the individual
- Choice over capability
- Belief and fighting for beliefs
- The diversity of humanity
- The endless nature of knowledge
- Only change is eternal
- Humanity's story





