Having now completed a playtest of the rough SA big book rules, I'll list here some of the things that I've run into regarding the game. These will be put in replies, so that each can be addressed in a different thread.
In the second session of my playtest, we had two unexpected guest players joining the ongoing adventure. Rather than waste time on character creation- and feeling that the Twist/Theme rules needed a serious testing, since the other players all had Tech ratings of 8-10- I made them both unenhanced baseline humans with all Capabilities at 1.
The Theme use seemed to work fairly well. The new system that has players buying Complications meshes better with the standard conflict resolution and works well as a comparison of effect. However, a few issues did arise.
The big question was, can Themes affect things on a large scale?
If no, then they suddenly become a lot less useful, as Capabilities CAN affect these things. If yes- then using the Large Scale Effects guidelines from Page 61, then a baseline human starts every game session with enough Twists to make a Civilisation spontaneously collapse. I suspect that some system similar to the old version, where extra Twists would be spent based on the scale/importance of the target needs to be added. I'd say the same categories as before- the Importance of the target (nameless NPC vs. Main Villain), the Duration, the Scale, etc- with -2, 0 and +2 replacing the 0/2/4 costs?
One Theme-related issue that did come up was how effective the team of high-Capability/high-Import PCs can be. When realising that the big obstacle for Twists is having to justify them in narrative terms, one PC worked out that the other PCs could use their tech as the justification. For example- a militant PC has Stringtech 5, Nanotech 5, and wants to wipe out an opposing army- but the scores are evenly matched and the opponenst motivated enough to escalate, making it a costly victory. So, said PC quickly constructs a gun and gives it to a baseline human with an Action Theme, who then spends Twists to justify wiping out the Stringtech 5 drone army he'd not been able to narratively justify himself beating with his fists.
Is this allowed, or is it not? Either way, it should be made clear in the rules that this is the case.
And finally- in a PC suffers some ill effect in a standard contest, can another PC step in to spend a Theme and rescue him from his Complications? Does this have the same cost as Plot Immunity for the PC who has the Themes? And if any PC, target or rescuer, doesn't have enough Themes for Plot Immunity, can they spend a lesser amount to reduce the level of the Complication they're taking?
I think you missed a few paragraphs:
As with individual-level Effects, the number in parentheses is used to rate the severity of the Complication or Advantage. To find the cost in Twists to create one of these Effects, multiply by one plus the level of Infrastructure for that group. For instance, creating a leak of classified information (Minor, 3) from a Society (typically Infrastructure II) would cost 3 x (2+1) = 9 Twists.
Because of the sheer number of Twists required, and the ten-Twist cap, it is typically impossible to buy this kind of Effect with a one-time Twist expenditure. Instead, use the Plot rules on page xx to generate long-term changes in the game world.
Having good narrative for your Twists is just good for the flow of the game; it's not to prevent you from using your Themes. It's perfectly ok to be inventive with them and to work with others to expand what's reasonable for your character. I'll put that in the advice section.
You can indeed get into the business of using one person's Themes to fix someone else's Complications. I encourage you to think of this as the "Circle of Ruin", because the Tech surcharge will quickly bleed the whole group dry of Twists.
Plot Immunity is an all-or-nothing expenditure. If you don't have the Twists, you need to take a Complication to get them.
Ah- I did indeed miss the Infrastructure multiplier. That would definitely have made a difference to things. I suppose that it's inevitable I'll miss a few rules given that reading revised versions of the same rules will give a tendency to miss changes.
And yes, this does make the whole Plots concept a much more solid game mechanic. Suddenly I'm getting what they're there for. I'll have to give them another look- and that will bring me to the next thing I've found in playtest in the second sub-thread here…
Now, this isn't a flaw with any rules specifically. Rather, it's something that the players and I realised when we discussed things after the playtest that I though was worth mentioning.
The second platest session ended up involving a great deal of collateral damage to the setting of the adventure. Three different PCs decided they'd wreck the place in three different ways, and another started plotting the total collapse of another PCs home Civilisation. The PCs had immense power available to them- they were either Capability-5 with inhuman skill/CV levels, or baseline humans with massive Twist reserves. Either way, the setting was their bitch and they were going to roll with that.
When considering sci-fi literature with similar tech levels to SA, the general reasons why such power doesn't get abused is because of the social consequences of doing so. Somewhere, somehow, somebody is going to take exception to these actions and make the perpetrators pay. Also, the actions could rebound on your own people, friends and family. So, people play nice and don't escalate things.
But- when a bunch of PCs are playing a one-off game with characters they've just made and won't play again in a setting they're not familiar with and so don't really care about…
Essentially, the players won't care about the consequences of their actions, especially when you've given them all these shiny, overpowered toys to play with and they're itching to use them. In a campaign, they'd think "Well, I want to try out my Stringtech 5 guns but I can wait until some bad guys attack us. It's an RPG, so that'll happen eventually". In a one-shot? "I'll probably not play this character again, there's one hour left before we pack up and leave- what the hell, who can I shoot…" Nobody used Stringtech in this session, that was just an example. But as anyone who knows the system will agree, high level Metatech and Congnitech aren't actually any less dangerous when employed without any regard for consequences.
This is probably something that's worth mentioning in the final book. The GMs will need to immediately make the players feel involved with their characters and the setting, because when they don't feel that- they start thinking about what they can do to make things interesting. You're suddenly playing the Powderkeg setting, regardless of what you thought you'd begun running.
Anyone else have thoughts on this?
From my own experience running one-shots, it depends a lot on the group. Some folks are more mission-oriented; others not only want to watch the world burn, they want to be the one holding the matches. I'd be glad to take some wise words from other folks to fold into the Advice chapter.
I've added an optional rule specifically for one-shots that reduces the payoff from Complications as you get later in the game, but it sounds like you're dealing with a separate issue.
On the plus side, high-level Meta and Cog should be just as dangerous, so I'm glad that worked out. :)
Another note about this - the default "first contact" setup that comes with the To The Stars setting has much larger tech differentials than most settings. Usually your team is not the only group with incredible technology at their fingertips.
Another of the issues from the playtest was the Conflict Table on page 38. This seems to have been reverted to multiples of the totals, rather than the Loser's Capability rating as in the last playtest draft.
I was finding the LC variable version gave much better results- with this version, all we seemed to get was Narrow Victories. Was there any major reason for this change?
I'd like to hear what it was if so. Going back to the old method- which I dutifully did for this second playtest- meant that conflicts seemed far more inconclusive, and the upper levels of the table might as well not have been there.
The goal was to speed things up. Referring back to the loser's Capability is one more back-reference that I wanted to cut out. No other reason.
The Conflict system is already quick enough compared to dice-based resolution that looking up the Loser's Capability makes no real difference to play time. And any gains aren't enough to balance out the far less satisfying range of results it gives out.
I don't know what other playtest feedback is going to say on this, but having tried both ways I definitely vote for sticking with LC over multiples of totals.
Fair enough. Anyone else have things to report here?





